Can you fight a pandemic non-compliance fine?

With states fining people thousands of dollars for non-compliance with pandemic travel restrictions, riders are understandably concerned about copping a fine for going on even a short ride.

Police have said officers will use their “judgement” and all fines will be assessed.

Queensland State Disaster Coordinator Deputy Commissioner Steve Gollschewski explains how they will approach the issue:

Where police will take action is if there are blatant or wilful breaches happening in the community.

It will then be up to riders to challenge the fine in court.

In this new “police state” of ours, riders could be fined for a short ride around their neighbourhood to “clear the cobwebs”, get a bit of sunshine and some light exercise, even  if they stay within all health guidelines and social distancing measures.

Pandemic ride responsibly

Non-compliance fines

At the moment there is a bunch of rules, suggestions and directives from health departments, politicians and police.

They don’t match and they vary from state to state. They are so confusing! (Click here to take our rider survey on pandemic restriction rules.)

What’s the difference and which do we obey?

In the end, it’s the police who issue the fines.

Police have reasserted that ignorance is never a defence, but surely it is in this case of hastily drafted rules that change so quickly and are contradictory.

So we asked Brisbane barrister and motorcyclist Levente Jurth for his opinion.

“Your questions are understandable, but you’ve asked for answers to hundreds, if not thousands, of variables, many of which continue to change on a daily basis,” he says.

“Obviously, I can’t respond to that.

“As a broad overview, I think the position is this: if someone is obviously doing the wrong thing and is being deliberately disobedient, then they will be punished if they get caught.

“On the other hand, anyone who is conscientiously trying to do the right thing and is doing their best to act in compliance with the applicable directives will likely be treated with some flexibility (eg. a warning), even if they have technically contravened a specific rule.”

If the matter does go to court, it could be some time until it is heard as courts are effectively closed for all but serious matters during the pandemic.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.